Insightlink Home

Employee Surveys Blog

Seven cool ideas why it's worth ditching Secret Santa

Posted by Insightlink on 01/25/23

Secret Santa is a popular tradition in many workplaces, where employees draw names from a hat and purchase small gifts for the person whose name they have drawn. While this can be a fun way to get to know your coworkers better, there are also several reasons why ditching Secret Santa may be worth considering. 

These include increased efficiency, reduced stress, and improved morale among employees. Whether you are a manager, employee, or simply an interested observer, here are seven cool ideas to consider as you weigh the pros and cons of ditching Secret Santa in your workplace.
office xmas party
Photo by Antenna on Unsplash
7 Cool Alternatives To Secret Santa
  1. Festive Vouchers
  2. Christmas Auction
  3. Caffeine Swap
  4. Wish List
  5. Pirate Santa
  6. Guess The Gift
  7. Mystery Bags
Increased Efficiency and Productivity
One potential issue with Secret Santa is that it can decrease employee efficiency and productivity. This is because it can often become a distraction, particularly during the holiday season when other work-related priorities are competing for everyone's attention. Additionally, many employees may feel stressed out trying to come up with an appropriate gift for their Secret Santa recipient, which can take time and energy away from other important tasks.
Thesis statement: While Secret Santa can be a fun holiday activity for employees, there are several employee engagement-related reasons why it may be worth considering alternative gift-giving options.
Secret Santa can be a great way to encourage collaboration, cooperation, and give employees the chance to get to know each other on a more personal level. However, there are several employee engagement-related reasons why it may be worth considering alternate gift-giving options for the holidays.
For instance, this kind of gift exchange could lead to unequal opportunities if an employee is unable to comfortably purchase a pricey gift or simply doesn’t have enough resources.
Alternatively, allowing employees to choose their own gifts through reward programs such as gift cards takes away any competitive elements and provides them with more freedom in choosing something they will actually appreciate. Additionally, this would allow employers to express their gratitude to their team members without having to take valuable time away from the workplace.
All things considered, instead of traditional Secret Santa activities, employers should consider giving their employees the freedom of choice that comes with alternative gifting options.
Limited gift options
In a traditional Secret Santa exchange, group members draw names from a hat and give anonymous gifts to the chosen person. This ensures anonymity and prevents any feelings of bias or favoritism while still allowing each person to express their creativity with gifts tailored specifically to the beneficiary. Drawing names from a hat also adds an element of fun to the process and provides participants something to look forward to as they help others get into the spirit of the season.
However, this approach can also limit the variety of gifts that can be given, as the gifter may not understand the recipient's interests or needs well. This is particularly problematic if employees are required to spend a certain amount on their gift, which could lead to undue financial stress for some and an excess of expensive items for others.
Additionally, this approach can make it difficult to ensure that gifts are fair and equitable for everyone involved. For these reasons, some employers may choose to use other methods of gift-giving in their Secret Santa exchanges.
Alternatively, this may lead to employees feeling unappreciated or undervalued if they receive a gift that is not meaningful or useful to them. This could include items that are too expensive for the recipient's budget or those that do not align with their personal preferences.
In addition, some people may feel pressured to spend more than they can afford or to give a gift that is not truly representative of their feelings toward the recipient. Because of these issues, employers may want to consider alternative methods of giving gifts during Secret Santa exchanges in order to ensure that everyone feels valued and appreciated.
Potential for awkwardness or discomfort
Being asked to buy a gift for someone can be awkward, especially when that person is unfamiliar to the employee. It can be difficult to select an appropriate item without having knowledge of the individual's likes and dislikes.
Additionally, there is the risk of offending them with the wrong choice. Furthermore, it may seem like an imposition on the employee's free time, leading to feelings of resentment if they are busy or working with limited funds.
For these reasons and more, many employees may feel uncomfortable when asked to purchase a gift for someone they do not know well.
This can lead to awkwardness or discomfort, particularly if the recipient does not appreciate the gift or if the gifter is unable to afford a pricey gift for the recipient
Receiving a disproportionate gift can lead to awkwardness and discomfort for both parties involved. This is perhaps exacerbated if the recipient does not appreciate the gift, whether due to its value being too low or too high.
Similarly, if the gifter struggles financially, this may cause them feelings of guilt and shame due to their inability to afford something more expensive. In any case, understanding the expectations of either side can help alleviate any potential discordance.
Employees not properly trained on different protocols and policies can lead to tension, misunderstandings, and conflict within the workplace. This miscommunication can be especially damaging to employee morale as it may make them feel undervalued or overlooked, resulting in an overall decrease in engagement with their work.
Additionally, when issues arise due to a lack of training, there is little trust between colleagues and managers, making collaboration difficult.
The element of surprise can be lost
The element of surprise adds mystery and revelry to the exchange, keeping it exciting and memorable. Secret Santa is fun in part because no one knows what they will be gifted and there are endless possibilities - whether it’s a practical item or something unconventional, anticipation and suspense carries great appeal for those looking to add some extra excitement into the holiday season.
The element of surprise can be absent in gift-giving if the gifter and recipient know each other well, or if the gifter cannot keep the recipient's identity a secret. In such cases, it is unlikely that the individual receiving the gift would be excited because they were expecting to receive it; instead, they may feel obligated to accept the item.
Therefore, maintaining a element of surprise when presenting gifts can lead to greater appreciation from the recipient and make for a more positive exchange between both parties.
Gift-giving should be an enjoyable activity for both the giver and receiver. However, if a gift is purchased out of obligation rather than genuine interest, it can detract from the pleasure of the occasion for everyone involved.
This can occur when gifting is viewed as simply a task to be checked off a list, or when it does not reflect an understanding of the recipient’s tastes and preferences. These situations can make gift-giving feel more like a chore than a celebration.
Alternative gift-giving options
Group gift-giving or gift exchanges are an interesting way to come together as a group and provide a meaningful gift to an individual or collective. Everyone can contribute in a way that reflects their unique style and interests, allowing the recipient to receive a thoughtful and personalized present.
Not only do these types of gifts serve as conversation starters, they give the opportunity for people to connect while also making someone feel special.
However, this requires more thought and planning, as the giver will need to research their intended recipient. They may also consider what kind of gift the person would like, whether or not it is within their budget, and how to show appreciation for the individual without over-indulging them.
Encourage employees to give meaningful and personalized gifts, such as handmade or homemade items or experiences rather than material possessions.
Have employees attend workshops and training sessions to help them learn more about the company’s protocols and policies and how to communicate effectively with each other to prevent misunderstandings.
Hold a group gift-giving or exchange event where everyone can contribute to an unforgettable present together. This could be done through a secret Santa-style exchange or by pooling together resources to buy a larger, more meaningful gift.
In addition to these strategies, employers may also consider providing additional support and resources for employees who need navigating the office environment. This could include offering access to counseling and mental health services, or developing mentorship programs that allow colleagues to connect with one another and learn from one another's experiences.
Ultimately, by investing in the wellbeing of employees and fostering a culture of collaboration and respect, organizations can help create a rewarding environment for all involved.
Showing appreciation to employees is an important part of showing them that their hard work and dedication are duly acknowledged. Consider alternative ways to express how much they mean to the organization other than traditional methods such as Secret Santa - for example, public acknowledgement, thank-you notes or personalized gifts from the company can have a major psychological impact in making them feel valued.
Even something as small as a sincere 'thank you' from executives can make all the difference in boosting morale and improving job satisfaction.
The focus on material gifts
Secret Santa and other gift-giving traditions can be a fun way to bring joy and love to the holiday season, but they often place too much emphasis on material gifts. This can encourage consumerism and throw us into debt by spending more money than we should in search of expensive presents.
Though it's natural to want to shower our loved ones with gifts, it's important to remember that the most meaningful gifts are often found in memories, shared experiences, activities and heartfelt words.
Alternative options such as volunteering or charitable giving can help shift the focus away from material possessions and towards giving back to others. These civic engagements provide valuable benefits to society, cultivate individuals’ compassion and create a better understanding of those different from us.
Through these activities, individuals gain rewarding experiences that give them purpose and the feeling of making an impact in the world instead of accumulating items. At its core, it’s about helping to make others’ lives better.
Employees who feel a sense of teamwork, collaboration, and social responsibility at their workplace experience greater levels of job satisfaction. They perceive a purpose in their work, which motivates them to put forth more effort.
This kind of organized environment fosters strong relationships. It creates an atmosphere built on trust and respect between team members, resulting in enhanced productivity and efficiency of the business as a whole.
While Secret Santa can be a fun holiday tradition for employees, there are several employee engagement-related reasons why it may be worth considering alternative gift-giving options.
These alternatives can offer more flexibility, reduce awkwardness or discomfort, and shift the focus away from material possessions. Alternative gift-giving options can also enhance employees' sense of workplace appreciation, recognition, and purpose.
comments powered by Disqus

Employee engagement is linked to profits
Employee Survey Demo
Employee Survey Pricing

Where does your company stand on each of the critical "4Cs" of employee engagement and satisfaction?
  • Commitment
  • Culture
  • Communications
  • Compensation
Find out with a benchmarked and validated 4Cs Employee Survey from Insightlink. Since 2001, one of the most trusted research companies in North America.

How many of each do you have?
  • Committed Loyalists
  • Change Seekers
  • Dissatisfied Compromisers
  • Satisfied Opportunists
Only the Insightlink 4Cs Employee Survey can give you the full picture and let you hear how your employees feel about their experience at your organization.


Insightlink Communications are experts in employee survey design, data collection and analysis. Since 2001 we've helped companies of all sizes measure and improve their employee satisfaction and engagement.

4Cs Blog Home

4Cs Blog Archives

Recent Posts

Enhancing Team Dynamics: Creative Strategies for Boosting Collaboration in Your Workplace

Building a Resilient Organizational Culture through Employee Programs

Why Friendships at Work Matter for Employee Engagement

Elevating Employee Engagement: Financial Training for a Happier, More Productive Workforce

5 Reasons Why LinkedIn Will Revolutionize Recruiting Process

Favorite Links

Employee Survey
Insightlink's Acclaimed 4Cs Employee Survey

Advanced Online Survey Platform for Pros

Quick & Easy Online Surveys

Home of the Gallup Q12

World at Work


Insightlink on SHRM

Engaged Employees Blog

HR ToolKit Guide to Employee Surveys
Good info on how to write surveys.

Insightlink 360
Makes 360 assessment surveys easy.

Online Employee Exit surveys.


Copyright © Insightlink Communications. All rights reserved.